Political Radar

`Defeats the whole purpose'

November 4th, 2013

State Rep. Sylvia Luke said Monday that the state House has tightened screening procedures for testimony on a marriage equality bill.

The House has committed to hearing from the 5,184 people who had signed up, but opponents have used the process to delay the marathon hearing.

Luke said the House Judiciary Committee and the House Finance Committee would not allow people to give proxy testimony for those who have signed up to testify but are not present.

She said that photo identification would be enforced to ensure people are indeed registered to testify. Lawmakers -- and the news media -- noticed irregularities where some people's registration numbers did not match their names.

"We really want to discourage individuals from telling others that they can come and give other people's names or talk on behalf of other people, because that's really going to be wasting that person's time, and they're being misled into thinking that's being allowed here," Luke told reporters. "That's not being allowed."

Luke, the chairwoman of the House Finance Committee, also noted that she has conducted her own committee hearings differently, cutting off testimony once it becomes repetitive.

"The way I run my hearings, this would not have happened," Luke said. "The way I run my hearings is, if there's duplication -- if people are saying the same thing -- I would automatically cut it off."

Luke said that at this point in the gay marriage hearing, "90 percent of the information is duplicative, but we made a commitment to hear testimony, because this is a serious issue, and this is important for a lot of people.

"We're allowing as many people to testify as much as we can. And that's why we want to stress again. Please refrain from trading numbers, because that doesn't help the process. I think we've shown goodwill, and we are here to hear the public, but if people are trying to get other people -- or trying to testify on behalf of other people -- then that kind of defeats the whole purpose of having this hearing."

*Update: Rep. Marcus Oshiro, in a memo Monday to Luke and Rhoads, the chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, challenged them to cite the rule that allows them to ask people for valid identification before they testify or restrict testimony by proxy.

"I have grave concerns that these reports, if found accurate, taints the fairness of these proceedings and taints the validity of any committee action resulting from them," Oshiro wrote.

House Majority Leader Scott Saiki said the committees have discretion over how to accept public testimony and conduct hearings.

Oshiro, who has been urging people to exercise their First Amendment right to be heard, set up a table near the entrance to the Capitol auditorium with a small sign that read: "Ask Me."

10 Responses to “`Defeats the whole purpose'”

  1. Especially Incognito:

    Propponents have the Freedom of Speech.
    Unless they plan their speeches in a group,
    Repeat assumptions will occur. Each is
    an individual and by coincidence they repeat
    is not the crime. Since they also have the courage
    to speak their mind in public, let them vote.
    All 5,181 speakers, each have one vote for or against.

    The crime is that
    legislature should at the same time take a vote
    from each speaker to determine the majority.
    Basing a poll on this, they can either let the whole
    public vote and have a "special" election
    or they as the legislature vote in meeting
    and then let the Governor sign, for or against.

    "Till Death do you part". I do or I don't.

  2. ohiaforest3400:

    The only thing that Marcus Oshiro has a "grave concern" about is the gratification of his own vanity.

  3. Eric Ryan:

    Common sense is often duplicative, Ms. Luke. Living proof that you can lead a politician to the truth, but you can't make her drink.

  4. Johnson:

    Rep. Oshiro is the very embodiment of a sore loser. "I should have become the next Speaker but that didn't work out, so I'm going to have hissy fits and hold my breath til I turn purple."

  5. sad:

    Bob Oshiro would have been ashamed of Marcus' behavior over this last week if he were still alive. At least this time its a memo and not him ranting in the gallery of the auditorium wearing t-shirt and shorts.

  6. Especially Incognito:

    Sounds just like those who opinionate on fox news.
    Such drama from losers who Lost to President Obama.
    It seems my TV still broadcasts in black and white.

  7. Especially Incognito:

    Notice it is now 5,184 instead of 5,181.
    Edited to show 3 more speakers.

  8. Auto de Fe:

    The only thing that BLAKE Oshiro has a "grave concern" about is the gratification of his own vanity.

  9. Conspiracy Theorists:

    Just to note, the 3 people who used those last 3 #'s spoke in opposition to SB1

  10. Especially Incognito:

    Only a number.
    When it comes time to vote,
    the people will have spoken.
    The people that also lead our government.

Leave a Reply

By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the Star-Advertiser's TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. Because only subscribers are allowed to comment, we have your personal information and are able to contact you. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, email commentfeedback@staradvertiser.com.